May 26 2004
AI3: Episode 17- Thrilla In Manilla
Ok, technically they’re not in Manilla, but Thrilla in Hollywood didn’t rhyme. This is the brawl to settle it all. It’s Rocky vs. Apollo. It’s Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. The Rock. Ok, maybe I went a little too far. But this is the show that we’ve all been waiting for.

Larry Bird vs. Magic Johnson
Tonight, we get two hours of Idol madness that they could really wrap up in two minutes, but I’m sure having Ryno Seacrest say hi and then Seacrest out in two minutes wouldn’t be good television. Co-hosting with Ryno are Christina Christian and my second REM sleep mistress, the beautiful and talented Jennifer Love Hewitt.

Ok, maybe more beautiful than talented
Jenny Love introduces LaToya London and she performs on an outdoor stage. She’s singing If You Don’t Know Me By Now and immediately shows that it really should be her battling Fantasia tonight. I guess she really does have a future because she’s wearing this fat choker with shiny stuff all around it (maybe diamonds?). Ryno goes into Diana’s makeup room and we get the peppy DeGarmo who says she slept like a brick last night. I wonder if that brick was wearing a corset? They go to Kimberly Caldwell, last year’s hotty, at the Georgia Dome in Atlanta surrounded by pro DeGarmo fans. It’s a little odd to have so much build-up even though the results are already in.
They showed a few quasi celebrities giving their predictions and after Nicole Ritchie picked Diana, she then said she couldn’t wait to have sex with Kobe Bryant. They cut to Fantasia’s makeup room and Fantasia pointed out that she needed two tubes of gloss for her lips. Clay Aiken is in North Carolina at the Greensborough Coliseum with all the crazy Barrino fans. Clay isn’t quite as good as Caldwell at looking pretty. He’s close, but not quite. Blake is somewhere smiling right now.
Christina Christian is interviewing Lionel’s outrageous daughter, Nicole. Once again, she says she can’t wait to have sex with Kobe Bryant. Jenny Love is back on the stage and she bounces along with my main man, Georgie Huff. He’s singing Me And Mrs. Jones and he says they got a thing going on. Just like Me And Ms. Hewitt. George reaffirms my thought that even he was better than Diana. If Jennifer Hudson comes out and sings next, it could be three in a row better than Diana.
Back to Ryno. He goes into Paula’s dressing room to interview Randall Jackson and Paula Abdul. Paula’s boobs are huge tonight. She’s trying to smuggle two canteloupes in her dress. Back to Christina Christian who is talking to someone I’d expect to be there, Ray Romano. He says that his vote would go to Fantasia. Back to Jenny Love. Uh oh, Jasmine Trias is singing next. I read somewhere that Jasmine and Camille have a concert in Hawaii that sold out in 4 hours. Those Hawaiians love their pop starlets. Jasmine is singing Midnight Train To Georgia which is so not her. Comparing Gladys Knight’s voice to hers is like comparing ice cream to horse manure. It’s odd how much I liked Jasmine in the beginning and how much I don’t like her voice now.
Ryno goes into Simon’s dressing room. Simon is showing the chest hair. You might be able to put a comb through it. Back to the real J. Lo. She cuts right to Christina who is interviewing Sharon Osbourne. Where’s Ozzy? I would pay to see that man interviewed right now. Tamyra Gray is singing the National Anthem, and the camera immediately cuts to the Fonz. Henry Winkler was the man. I still pop my collar like the Fonz. Ryno says there were 65 million votes last night. I wish I could vote for the president by phone. Ryno introduces Randall, cantaloupes, and chest hair. And then he goes right to Diana and Fantasia who are dueting. Wait, it’s a threesome, I mean Kelly Clarkson comes out, showing some belly. Wait, it’s a menage a four. And the dog pile crusher himself, Rube Studdard comes out. Rube has been out there exactly 20 seconds and he’s already sweating buckets. It would be perfect if only Justin Guarini came out. But I think I saw him last on the back of a milk carton. Where are you Justin Guarini?
Back to Clay Aiken who is still in North Carolina. Fantasia is smiling. And she needs dental work. Ryno throws it back to Kim Caldwell at the Georgia Dome. She interviews Diana’s choir teacher who is almost hotter than Kim. And she starts interviewing the Mayor of Snellville who isn’t quite as hot as the choir teacher.
Kelly Clarkson is back singing Beautiful Disaster from her Thankful album and I’m thankful that she’s not showing her belly anymore. You know, I have this thing with Kelly where to me, she looks like a kin of Rosie O’Donnell. And that my friends, is not a good thing, it’s a bad thing. The wife just said her dress was actually not a beautiful distaster, but more along the lines of a horrible disaster. Ok, enough about her look tonight. The girl can sang.
Uh oh, the top 12 are back singing tributes to the guest judges. Georgie is leading Reach Out. Matt, JPL, and Baby Dean are singing background. The girls are singing Gloria Estefan, and baby girl, Camille starts off first. Leah Labelle jumps in after Camille. And then it goes to, um Amy Adams. I had forgotten about her. And she showed back up into my life. The nightmares, the nightmares. They cut into some Donna Summers and then into Ashford and Simpson with Solid As A Rock. Baby Dean got a few lines in with the ode to Big Band. Diana and the boys sing I’m Still Standing.
They just showed the Fonz again. I think he gave an “Aye” with a double thumbs up. Jenny Hudson and LaToya are singing Barry Manilow. I think they just showed Teena Marie in the audience, but I’m not sure. Rick James wasn’t there bitch! Sorry, it wasn’t Teena Marie. Big Rube Studdard is next with a horrible single What If. You know I love Big Rube. But his album is horrible. He has this line, “I love you like I used to love cake.” Dude, be real, you still love cake homey. This song has some of the worst lyrics you’ll ever hear.
What if I was broke?
What if I was slim?
What if I couldn’t sing and I didn’t win?
What if I had to catch the bus?
I still stay wit my momma so there ain’t no making love
Baby what if I had to used the payphone just to get my game on?
Would you still wanna put it on me?
In a classy move, Rube unveils his quadruple XL Luther Vandross shirt.
Diana sings the song she did last night written by Tamyra, I Believe. I’m going to guess that Fantasia is going to do it too? Diana does a better job than she did last night, but guess what? The votes have already been counted. Fantasia is singing Dreams. Darn, I wanted her to sing All My Life again. I think Diana’s performance was much better but guess what? The votes have already been counted.
Before we get the results, Diana and Fantasia duet with I Knew You Were Waiting or something like that. They do a commendable job, but I’m just waiting for the results. Simon says AI is the best talent show on earth. Paula says she’s proud. Randall says he’s proud too. Like a big old Papa Bear. Drum roll, please. Ryno is ready to let us know who the winner is.
And the winner is:
Fantasia Barrino
Fantasia takes us out with her new single, I Believe.
For one last time, like Ryno Seacrest, I’m out.

