Nov 29 2004
Memo To The 49ers
To Dennis Erickson, Terry Donahue, the ghost of George Seifert, one of Eddie D’s old pocket books, or whoever else it may concern:
Let me preface this by saying I’m already sold. I’m a 49er fan for life. Even if they go 1-15 for the next 10 years. I’m here. No need to lie to me, or make excuses.
Now that I got that out of the way. I’m pretty much owed this horrible season as a 49er fan right? Hell, I was born in 1976, woke up to football in 1983, watched Joe Montana, Steve Young, Jerry Rice, Ronnie Lott, Roger Craig and all of the other near hall of famers day in and day out. I have watched 4 Super Bowl victories of my favorite team live in my living room. How many people can say that? I have told numerous Raider fans, “scoreboard” when they try to talk down my Niners. All they can come up with is “Forty Whiners”, which I’ve never got because how can you whine when all you do is win Super Bowls? I even bought a Deion Sanders 49er jersey for the one season “Prime Time” was wearing the red and gold. Kool-Aid? Hell, I sold it on a stand for 49 cents a cup. I should be relegated to more 1-10 starts as a 49er fan now right? It’s like the kid who gets 20 presents every Christmas. Yep, that’s me. And now, that Christmas tree only has pine needles under it. But I’m not upset at the prospect of losing. I just hate being told something that I can see with my own eyes as untrue.
When I hear that Tim Rattay is the best fit for the 49ers short term needs, I gag. But I haven’t always felt this way. Last year when Jeff Garcia was hurt, I figured it wasn’t a bad idea to give Rattay a shot. TO sure wanted him to play. Hell, if TO wanted it, it couldn’t be that bad right? And he played well. The thing I noticed about him is that he seemed to not really wilt under pressure. Sometimes when Garcia would get excited, he’d jump and throw a ball into the ground, or he’d run around like a chicken with it’s head cut off and end up missing someone who was wide open. But not Rattay. He seemed to be even headed, almost cool-like. He usually made the smartest read, maybe not the highest risk/reward type of read, but usually good enough to keep the offense on the field. And even early on this year, he still seemed like that player. And now I don’t know if it’s the new coffee he’s been drinking, or maybe his underwear is too tight, but he is now a complete 180% from what I saw last year. He’s ancy in pocket. He doesn’t sit still. He doesn’t step up in the pocket enough. And worst of all, he does the one thing that you don’t want your quarterback to do. He panics. Now I’m not a doctor, and I don’t play one on television. Hell, I never even played doctor as a child with the fake stethoscope. But I would like to put a blood pressure monitor on him when the blitz comes. I’d guess his heart rate and blood pressure shoot so high that it’s not healthy. And maybe that’s the reason we should give the NFL so he can go on the injury list. Unhealthy heart beat.
I can live with incompletions. I can live with bad dump-offs to running backs who have no where to go. I can almost live with that bad pass into the defense when they figure out you’re running a screen, but you haven’t figured out that they’ve figured it out. Yes, I can almost live with that one. But I can’t live with the late 4th quarter game losing interceptions. I can’t live with the fumbles at the end of the game that the teams scoop up and turn into touchdowns. Those are will killing. I would love for Bill James to come up with a stat that shows how often a QB loses points. Almost like the plus/minus hockey stat. How many TD’s is Tim Rattay responsible for the defense scoring?
Now, I haven’t played football since I was 12, but I play baseball. And I guess Rattay’s horrendous 4th quarter play is analogous to when my closer comes in and immediatly can’t find the plate, walks the bases loaded and only finds the plate long enough to serve up a game losing grandslam. That’s will killing. And you know how people say that Joe Montana, John Elway, and Brett Favre are 4th quarter comeback quarterbacks? What does that make Rattay? The 4th quarter give back quarterback? That brings me to Ken Dorsey. Can he be worse than will killing Rattay? In the games he’s played this year, he’s been bad. But he hasn’t been will killing. All you hear is that Dorsey is the future. Isn’t the future now? I mean, there’s zero pressure right now. It can’t get any worse. Give Dorsey the reps in practice and see what he can do. Don’t even bench Rattay. Just say he has an unhealthy heart beat or something and put him on IR. I mean, you can’t just kill Rattay’s will right? Like Keyshawn once said, “Just give Dorsey the damn ball!” Ok, maybe he wasn’t talking about Dorsey, but you get the picture.
Now onto the defense. It’s commendable. It never quits. Your defense is playing with 5th string corners. I’ve never even heard of the guy who made the interception yesterday. I saw M. Adams on his jersey and immediately thought of the old three-point shooting guard from the Denver Nuggets in the late 80’s. So how can I blame them? Julian Peterson, the best player probably on the team, out for the year. Ahmed Plummer hasn’t seen the field in two months. Andre Carter was out so early in the season, I thought we traded him in the offseason. The defense isn’t will killing. They are what’s keeping the fans in the games. You watch Bryant Young anchor that defensive line. He has zero help. John Engelberger seems to play 2 games a year because the other 14 games you never see him. And don’t get me started on Brandon Whiting because that will get me started on how you could trade one of the MVP candidates in all of football and only get a third round pick and a guy who lives on the injured list named Brandon Whiting. And bringing up Brandon Whiting also reminds me of Terrell’s good buddy Jeff, who reminds me that my team is paying him $10 million dollars to play in Cleveland. And bringing up Brandon Whiting, who reminds me of TO, who reminds me of Jeff, also reminds me that if we’re paying Jeff to play in Cleveland, couldn’t we have paid him to play in San Francisco? Or is that a part of what Mr. Donahue calls taking our medicine? That same medicine that we took 3 years ago and were told that we wouldn’t have to take again. Must be flu season.
Basically, the defense plays hard, but let’s stop saying how good we are. Or the great quote, “Just wait until we’re healthy.” I hate that. Isn’t one of the great things about having supposed depth is that when injuries happen, you just plug in a new guy? Can you ever be completely healthy in football? Ever?
I’m ready for the first pick in the NFL draft. I can taste it. I’m ready to see Aaron Rodgers, Matt Leinert, that one DB Rolle (not Esther Rolle), or anyone else who Mel Kuiper Jr. can sell me as a can’t miss prospect. But I never thought it’d come to this. I mean, only Indianapolis and San Diego should be getting the first pick of the draft every year. I never thought the glorious franchise that is the 49ers would have fallen so far. Does the franchise even equate what it used to mean anymore? Do players look forward to coming here? Or do we have to stoop to the whole Bay Area climate deal to sell people like the Warriors do? And aren’t they aghast when they see house prices? Ouch. Maybe we’ll have to sell them more. Automatic dates with cheerleaders or getting them shows on Sirius satellite radio or something. Strip clubs. We have borderline against the law strip clubs in San Francisco. Maybe we can give them free funny money. Athletes and T&A. Great fit if you ask me. Maybe Jerry Rice would come back and strictly play for funny money. Why hasn’t anyone thought of this before?
I guess what I’m trying to say is that just don’t lie to us. If we’re gonna suck, tell us we’re gonna suck. Don’t tell us that we’re better than anyone gives us credit for. Or that we’re not a 1-10 team. Or that we have good quarterbacks and this is a quarterback franchise. Or that we have receivers that are much better than our number one pick this year and that’s why he’s not playing. Or that Kevan Barlow is a top ten running back in this league. Because then we see NFL Europe castoff Maurice Hicks splitting playing time with him and starting doing the whole, “well if Barlow is top ten, then Hicks must be top ten.” No, actually if we did that, we’d be idiots, but you get my drift. Don’t tell us that this defense has young future stars. Young future stars actually sack the quarterback and intercept passes. They don’t “almost” get there. They get there. And wait, haven’t some of these guys like Carter, Winborn, Ulbrich and Plummer been here for a while already? If they were ever going to be stars, wouldn’t they already be? Aren’t we wasting Tony Parrish’s prime years as well?
Ok, you get my drift. To sum up my vent, and if you need to ever come back to this to take notes, just read these points rather than my emotional rant again.
- Play Dorsey over Rattay
- Don’t pretend to tell us how good our defense is even if we’re injured (it’s only as good as it’s playing right now)
- Don’t ever remind us about TO and Jeff Garcia because it brings bad thoughts that only show how much you screwed up both deals
- Please use this first pick wisely. Please. I’m on my knees. Begging even.
- Don’t lie. It’s the reverse Nike slogan. Just don’t do it.
Respectfully yours,
49er Fan
BWalsh (and the B does not stand for Bill)
Now there are a few things that help separate the iPod from the other
And lastly, my best friend El Horrible got one right. But only because I told him who it was! Bastard! He didn’t have a guess for the first one, but then guessed right by saying Young Keyshawn was the second person. Yes, Keyshawn Johnson. Let me explain.
As for the first quote, it comes a new feud between Jay-Z and R. Kelly. Jay-Z and R. Kelly recently put out a new album called Unfinished Business. In touring to support the album, they had a couple dates at Madison Square Garden. Supposedly, Kelly received a death threat before the show and went on stage worried for his life. (I think the man’s on drugs, but that’s neither here nor there.) He supposedly saw two men in jackets point to something that Kells thought might be a gun, and left the stage. Jay-Z was frustrated at the thought of not finishing the concert dates and missing out on a second Madison Square Garden concert because of Kelly’s unprofessionalism. Jay-Z then said, “I had five outfits under the bed crispy waiting for New York City… and this is what I get.”