Before the last show from Season 4 in which Carrie Underwood defeated Boseph Bice, I started off my review with this:
There?s a good chance that this is going to be my final American Idol show wrap up post, mostly because I?ve found that it?s so hard to watch the show and have the energy to write about it within a decent time frame. So, unless I start doing this another way, you might want to have a moment of silence for this report. One second was good enough for me. On with the show.
And then I ended with this, causing Idol fans to weep.
Mama told me one day it was gonna happen
But she never told me when
She told me it would happen when I was much older
Wish it would?ve happened then
Is this the end?
Since New Edition can get back together, I think I can do this again. Like Michael Jordan said one time, I’m back. It’s that simple.
Let’s start with famous Hot List.
The Hot List
1. Chris Daughtry - Leader in the clubhouse.
2. Katharine McPhee - The vocal surprise of the show.
3. Paris Bennett - Paris is my favorite female performer.
4. Elliot Yamin - The boy has soul.
5. Lisa Tucker - She’s the most polished of the youngsters.
6. Taylor Hicks - He’s the best 40 year old ever.
7. Mandisa - Please dress this woman better and her ranking will go up.
8. Ace Young - Has the look, but he needs to bring up the singing game.
9. Kellie Pickler - Women will turn on her soon unless she starts singing better.
10. Bucky Covington - He’s the wildcard here.
11. Melissa McGhee - She needs to come up big here.
12. Kevin Covais - The fact that he’s here is a misjustice.
For this season, I’m taking this show on the road. Like Ludacris who goes pimpin’ all over the world, I’m going to drop in and watch this show with fans all over the world. Ok, maybe just the United States. You’ll definitely find me in the Bay Area. You might find me in Texas, or New York, or Virginia. I’ll be crashing living rooms all over. If you get a knock at the door and you’re not sure who it’s from, it could be me. Just answer the door.
Tonight, I’m at the house of Michelle and Val in rainy South San Francisco. You’ll get comments from them, as well as from Meeks and the one and only, the man, the myth, the legend, THE BITO~! We are sitting in the living room with two huge 60 inch big screens and a killer surround system. This is the way everyone must watch this show.
If you want to hear a killer podcast previewing American Idol Season 5 this is a must listen. You’ll learn all you need to know.
Alright, Ryno Seacrest is here. That only means that it’s time. It’s game time. He’s looking quite dapper, but Michelle already said that his tie looks like a sock.
To make this show even better, it’s “Stevie Wonder Night”. I can’t wait for someone to mess up Higher Ground.
To start off the night, it’s Acey Young. Acey says that Stevie Wonder doesn’t only battle his handicap, but he also battles LIFE~! Acey is doing Do I Do and though he messed up early on and his dancing is severely lacking, there’s a quality he has that not everyone has. The camera likes him. Where’s his beanie cap? He’s also trying to sing it in Stevie’s voice. It was decent. He finished and his hands were literally shaking. Randall says he started off badly, he got it together, but it was only a’ight. Paula disagrees and says he started off the night fantastic. Paula, use your adverbs dear. It’s fantastically. Simon says it wasn’t a great vocal and it won’t be the best vocal performance tonight and called it manic. Guest judge Meeks says in her best Tony the Tiger voice, “It was greaaaaaaat”.
Next is Kellie Pickler who looks like an absolutely different human being. What doing ones hair does to someone. She’s going to sing Blame It On The Son and this is a great song, but it’s not necessarily the happiest song. Unfortunately Kellie doesn’t necessarily have the charisma nor the chops to pull this thing off. But again, she looks like someone else. I think this girl in front of us took Kellie Pickler, locked her inside a room and took her place. The song gets a little better near the middle, but her singing is not even where it should be. Randall says that it was a non-event and it didn’t really happen. Paula says that you could tell that she was nervous and out of her comfort zone and was too safe. Simon says that everything went wrong and that it was so boring and it wasn’t going to end and that she looks like Dolly Parton, but sans the boobs of course. THE BITO~! simply says that it sucked, but he thinks she’ll get through on her cuteness factor.

It’s Stevie Night
Elliot Yamin is next and I’m going to predict that he’s going to excel here. This is his style of music. He’s going to sing Knocks Me Off My Feet which is one step below Ribbon In The Sky in my book. Elliot is knocking it out of the park. It isn’t his best vocal because he looks quite nervous, but this man can sing. He might look like a backup’s backup singer, but the dude can blow. Michelle says that Elliot is quite good, and THE BITO~! adds that he’s quite ugly. Thankfully THE BITO~! isn’t brokeback. Randall says it wasn’t his best, but he was good at the end. Paula says that he’s an amazing singer and that he’ll stick around, and it won’t even be funny. Simon says that there wasn’t much wow factor and that he was nervous.
Mandisa had Ryno take off her shoes because they hurt. The problem wasn’t her shoes, but more so the fact that she stuffed her foot into a shoe that prohibits any sort of stuffing. She’s going to sing Don’t You Worry ‘Bout A Thing and I predict greatness here as well. There’s still something about the outfits Mandisa chooses that bothers me. The make-up and hair is slammin’ though. The thing about Mandisa is that she’s got such a powerful voice and she can probably sing the phone book and it’d be great. I like the performance, but wasn’t blown away. She does veer off a little at the end and try to make it a little bit different which was good. Randall says that she’s the best so far. Paula says she can sing anything. Simon says that it’s the best so far. Val says she wasn’t quite paying attention, but that she’s not worrying ‘bout a thing. I think we’re going to go solely with THE BITO~! from now on.
Bucky Covington is next and he’s doing Superstition. You know how I said that Kellie looked like an entirely different human being? Well Bucky looks like Bucky. Actually, he looks like Bucky with a nice perm~! While Bucky’s voice is not conducive to R&B music necessarily, he has a good enough voice to pass it off as good. Randall says that he was excited and he enjoyed it. Paula says that it was different, but she wished he would’ve tried to get out of his comfort zone. Simon says it was one of the best so far, but compared his hair to that of Jessica Simpson. THE BITO~! disagreed and originally says that she sucked.
Melissa McGhee is next and let’s just say that she’s wearing the right dress tonight. She’s singing Lately which is basically a song where a man thinks his woman is cheating on him. Thus, she tries to change the lyrics and it comes off really badly. Poor Melissa. This will be her last day. And she is screwing up the lyrics that she is actually trying to sing. This could be one of the worst Idol performances ever. Randall says that she forgot her lyrics but she finished up strong. Paula says she should wear dresses more often and I agree with that. They caught the same missed lyrics that I did. And she says she did well. Simon says it was her best performance thus far. THE BITO~! says once again, she sucked. THE BITO~! is not a happy man tonight.
Lisa Tucker is next and she’s singing Signed, Sealed, Delivered. She’s got a little fashion going on tonight and doesn’t look her usual self and is showing off some 17 year old cleavage. She looks like Aaliyah tonight. I really wish she would’ve done a ballad. She had gusto, but if I’m Randall, I’d say for me, for her, it wasn’t my favorite. Randall says it got hot at the end. Paula says that something that I didn’t hear because of my rude audience members. Simon says that he enjoyed it very much. THE BITO~! says creatively that she was good.
Kevin Covais is next and he’s singing Part Time Lover. I’ve never heard this song sung with a lisp, but we’ll hear it now. This has a William Hung quality to it. And that’s the good parts. Wow, this was just not good. Randall says he sang it good and in tune. Paula says that it was in tune, and it was in style, with his own strange dance steps. Simon says Stevie would’ve turned down the volume and it was appalling. THE BITO~! says he didn’t like it at all.
My good friend Low Jones called Katharine McPhee, Katharine McPhever and said that he was very fond of her in many ways and she makes him tingle. She’s singing Until You Come Back To Me. I know Stevie didn’t sing this, but I guess he wrote it. Katharine may have the best voice in this competition on the female side. Her dress is awful and she looks like Britney Spears during her Federline days (ok, not that bad), but damn she’s got the voice of an angel. Randall says that she was off the chain and calls her dude. Paula says it was her best performance. Simon says she’s reminding him of Kelly Clarkson. She doesn’t only sound like her, she looks a little like her too. THE BITO~! says she’s good and that he likes her a lot, but wasn’t a fan of the dress.
Taylor is singing Living For The City. Taylor is dressed to the nines in a PHAT suit. You feel like he’s one of the people that can actually get into the lyrics of something like this. He’s lived a little. Taylor is trying to morph into Michael McDonald in front of our very eyes. Randall says he was fearless. Paula says that it had a lot of passion and she loved it. Simon says he’s like every dad who has gotten drunk at a wedding, but the difference is, that he can sing. THE BITO~! wasn’t paying much attention as he says he didn’t want to watch old men sing. He just doesn’t understand.
Paris is singing All I Do looking like a young Lauryn Hill. Where’s Michael singing the hook when you need him? Paris is rocking out. This might be the best performance of the night. She understands how to perform and makes it look natural. Though I’m not sure she’s ever worn heels in her life. Great job for young Paris. Meeks decided to pay attention for once and said she was very professional. Randall says she was unbelievable. Paula says she was a seasoned veteran. Simon says she’s a performing little doll.
We have one more to go and it’s the leader in the clubhouse, Chris Daughtry. By the way, this two hour show is killing me. But we’re almost done. Chris is singing Higher Ground. The thing about Chris is that he gets it. He understands his strengths. Even though he shaved off his facial hair and is nearly babyfaced. He’s singing it very much the way the Chili Peppers did. He does a really good job to close the show. Randall says that every week he figures out a way to make it his own. Paula says what she usually does when she glows. Simon says that he could’ve put that on record.
THE BITO~! thinks that Katharine McPhee is going to win it all. Michelle agrees. Val says that she wasn’t quite paying attention enough, and Meeks was too busy MySpacing.
I must do this again. And it feels so good. Seacrest, out!