Before we get started with tonight’s final night of competition, I wanted to make you aware of one thing, and give you some inside information on another.
First, I gave my thoughts on the season as a whole as well as a preview of tonight’s show yesterday and you can read it here. I was yelled at by a Constantine fan (and yes, I think he was a guy) in the comments section. But I got him back.
And here’s the inside news. Word on the street is that Simon Cowell was very upset after Melinda Doolittle’s ouster last week. I have sound of his reaction backstage after the show was over. You can listen below.
That was an angry Cowell.
Tonight is the night. Two shows left. Blake versus Jordin. Jordin is the better singer, does American Idol music better than Blake, is taller, and doesn’t try to look like Corey Feldman. So why do I have this feeling that Blake will win? I’m not sure, but it’s a gut feeling. Can he beat box his way to the top? Should he duet with Doug E. Fresh? That’s what tonight is for. And we have the luxury of not having to see Taylor Hicks’s horrible purple velvet coat tonight. We’re ahead of the game already.
The Hot List
1. Jordin Sparks - She and Shirley Bassey love us.
2. Blake Lewis - Blake’s girl gives love a bad name?
The Departed
1. Young Brandon Rogers
2. Young Stephanie Edwards
3. Young Chris Sleigh
4. Young Gina Glocksen
5. Young Haley Scarnato
6. Young Sanjaya Malakar
7. Young Phillip Stacy
8. Young Chris Richardson
9. Young Lakisha Jones
10. Young Melinda Doolittle
Tonight is a little bit different. I don’t only have a few guest judges with me tonight. I have tons of guest judges. Everyone who was a part of these write-ups was invited back to help create the most comprehensive Idol commentary out there. Here’s a list of the guest judges who are back. Wait, there is one new one. He’s an Epinions Category Lead, but also a good friend. George (aka Joubert) is going to help us out tonight too. Better late than never.
Guest Judges
I am at my dear mother’s house tonight and in attendance with us is my sister and Shoesless. And that also means that I’m watching it in HD~! They tease Paula who broke her nose by tripping over her dog. And Ryno calls Simon, Simon Cleavage and the chest hair is flowing tonight.
My mom thinks that Blake Lewis looks like my cousin Tomiko’s boyfriend Dan, known here in this space simply as The Coach. I guess I can see it if I squint a little. And I think they’re the same size if Coach is on his knees.

Does Coach Look Like Blake?
After a coin flip, Blake wins the right to choose who should go first and Blake decides to go first after asking Jordin what she wanted to do. The Coach would’ve done the same thing.
They are singing three songs each. One is their favorite performance, one is something they’ve never performed before, and one is a song called This Is My Now, which is the winning song from the songwriting contest they had running this season.
Blake starts with You Give Love A Bad Name and either he dyed his hair purple or there is some wacky lighting. This performance is pretty much right on the money except he nearly dropped the mic when he went back to sing the hook. He was a little bit excited, but still did a fine job. He did the Luchadors proud. By the way, they were split on who was going to win. Luchador 1 thought Blake would win, while Luchador 2 thought Jordin would. Randall says the beat boxing was hot but the singing was just alright. Paula says he outdid himself. Simon says he’s the best performer even though he’s not the best singer.
My dear mother - Blake did good and he’s a performer and that’s what I like about him. Not everyone has a great voice, but if they can perform, that’s what takes care of it.
Sis - It was good and I liked the battle with the drummer.
Shoesless - I liked the beat boxing and he mixed it good and it sounded original.
Jessica - Why couldn’t he sing Time Of The Season? You Give Love A Bad Name was a very entertaining and creative performance, but Time Of The Season was the one performance that really showed off his singing abilities.
Patty - I’m not a fan of messing with Bon Jovi songs so I just didn’t enjoy his rendition but he performed it like a pro.
George - Yeah, my favorite song this year! He missed the first note and nailed everything else.
Shantel - That’s my Blake!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AWESOME!
Amy - A great revisit of his best performance of the season.
Andrew - Blake’s re-mix of the Bon Jovi hit shows why I really enjoyed him every week - energy + experimentation = entertainment.
Blake - It was a solid performance and still as entertaining as the first time he did it.
HJ - STILL LOVED IT.
Young Randall - It was nice the first time I heard it, but I hated it the other 6 times (HJ on the rewind) and especially this one.
Eddy Zucko - Didn’t hear it the first time he performed it, but from what I heard it was great. So I was kinda disappointed when I heard it tonight. Was that supposed to be Blake greatness?
The Bito~! - I love this song! It really fits his style. It’s the song that he’ll always be known for.
Lionel Ritchie - The beat boxing was great! Say you, say me, say it together, that’s the way it outrageously should be.
Judge for yourself.
Blake - You Give Love A Bad Name
Jordin is singing Christina Aguilera’s Fighter. She has straight hair. She just broke the Joyfulgirl’s heart. Jordin comes off a bit flat. And I think singing Christina is a mistake. It’s very much like Melinda singing Whitney Houston last week. She starts to pick it up, but the only thing this song does for her is show that she’s not in Christina’s league vocally. Who is? That’s not the point. By the end of the song I wanted to hear Christina, not Jordin. Randall says her voice was stellar and brilliant. Paula says she was stellar. Simon says he liked the younger song but the vocals were a bit shrieky and gives round one to Blake.
My dear mother - She didn’t blow me away with the song choice. I didn’t get anything from her singing it.
Sis - It was alright and got better in the end. But she didn’t perform it, she just sang it.
Shoesless - It wasn’t one of her best performances and I expected a lot more.
Jessica - Why hasn’t the American Idol vocal coach taught Jordin how to breathe? It could’ve been a great performance if she weren’t gasping for air.
Patty - It was good, but not finale-worthy for me.
George - Risky Xtina choice shows off her youth and chops, especially her versatility.
Shantel - Um, she’s got pipes but I did NOT like that song on her at all. Way too over the top.
Amy - She completely sold the song.
Andrew - Jordin’s fighting the tempo and the tempo is winning; a good song choice for her range but she doesn’t have control of it.
Blake - Her vocals were ok on this. Didn’t sound as good as some of the stuff she’s done in the last couple of weeks.
HJ - Pitchy, did not like it too much.
Young Randall - It wasn’t a great performance, but it was better than Blake. She sang it a bit nervously.
Eddy Zucko - Xtina would be proud. Except Xtina would have sang the song naked.
The Bito~! - Damn, a Christina song? Why bother? You can’t compete with her.
Lionel Ritchie - I think she’s related me somehow. She was wailing outrageously.
Judge for yourself.
Jordin - Fighter
It’s Blake’s turn again and this time he’s singing Maroon 5’s She Will Be Loved. I am a fan of this song and his voice channels Adam Levine very well, but if he’s going to try to out sing Jordin, that’s the wrong strategy. It’s a solid singing performance, but I wanted to see more performing. He has troubles with the falsetto, but other than that, it’s good enough. Randall says it was a great song and a great vocal. Paula says he sounded great and relaxed. Simon says it was good and safe but wasn’t as good as the first performance and wasn’t impactful.
My dear mother - I liked it. I thought he did really well. I don’t think he needs to have a great voice to win.
Sis - It was nice. It wasn’t a whole lot, but it was nice.
Shoesless - It wasn’t as good as the first song and he didn’t take much of a chance.
Jessica - Blake is my boyfriend and you need to stop calling him Corey Feldman because it’s mean.
Patty - Ehhh. Good for week six but not for the finale.
George - Adam worship continues, but first falsetto is sloppy as he tries to out sing Jordin.
Shantel - LOVE when he sings Maroon 5 songs! Loved it! WHOOOOOOOOOOO!
Amy - This was a chance to show off his unique vocal style. It was very good but not perfect.
Andrew - Blake understands what works for his voice - even if he’s not the best singer (and pitchy at times), he still sells it.
Blake - Although there were a couple of pitchy spots on the high notes, it was a pretty good vocal.
HJ - It was OK. I like Maroon 5 singing it better. It’s kind of slow but it fits his style of voice.
Young Randall - His version of the one Maroon 5 song that I like was just OK. He never did anything to wow me and still has done nothing.
Eddy Zucko - His best performance of the season.
The Bito~! - He knows what songs fit him. He can’t beat Jordin’s strong vocals, but it was a great song for him.
Lionel Ritchie - When I covered this song, it was called, “She Will Be Loved Outrageously”.
Judge for yourself.
Blake - She Will Be Loved
By the way, this show misses Melinda dearly. And Sanjaya.
Jordin’s next performance is A Broken Wing which she performed on country night. This is the right song for her because she can tie up this ballgame with a really good performance. I’m not fond of her outfit, but she’s singing Blake under the table. She one upped her great performance from when she previously did this song. Randall says it was flawless and unbelievable and said it was better than the original. Martina McBride just fell off her couch. Paula says she is in great vocal voice. Yep, that’s what she said. Simon says it was good.
My dear mother - She did a good job, but I still didn’t get goosebumps.
Sis - It was good. (She really loved it and said she had goosebumps, but I think Shoesless made her mad.)
Shoesless - I felt more of a connection with this song and she built it up to a crescendo.
Jessica - I really like her outfit and that song is my favorite song she performed all season, but I liked it the first time she did it better.
Patty - She has a beautiful voice and I loved it.
George - Again blows by Martina, but does she oversing it? The quiet notes are good too.
Shantel - The middle and end of the song was AMAZING! Much better than first song.
Amy - Great singing but a somewhat lackluster performance.
Andrew - Jordin comes roaring back out of her corner and takes Round Two, packing a wallop in that voice of hers.
Blake - Best vocal of the season for her and a very good performance.
HJ - Better song, i like it when she sings slower songs.
Young Randall - That was excellent. She sang her young arse off on this one. She may have won it right here, but I said the same thing about Bo Bice on his second song.
Eddy Zucko - Like Black Randall said, sang it better than the original…poor Martina.
The Bito~! - Great voice as always, she’s awesome… but a country song? What audience is she going for?
Lionel Ritchie - I can’t think of any other word other than outrageous! We must be cousins.
Judge for yourself.
Jordin - A Broken Wing
Blake is singing This Is My Now. I wonder if it helps or hurts him to go first. Blake’s wearing some gnarly shoes. I’m not so sure this song is going to help him very much. It’s very slow. It starts off like a regular contemporary ballad and then transitions into a country ballad. As it picks up, he picks it up. About half way in, I was ready for the song to be over. I think he did ok with it, but the song isn’t all that special. Randall says he did a pretty good job and it was alright. Paula says it wasn’t his genre but he was in great voice. Simon says it was odd. This might lose him the competition.
My dear mother - I thought he did well. How much can you do with this song?
Sis - That song wasn’t made for him. The arrangement, the back-up singers. It reminded me of when I was in choir and I was singing well, but the back up singers weren’t.
Shoesless - I was underwhelmed. The first two were what you need to judge him on.
Jessica - If only I had ten dollars, I totally could’ve won that writing contest if that’s the winner.
Patty - Corny song and pretty average.
George - Not judging the song, but this true entertainer sold this puppy even with weak hooks.
Shantel - So this wasn’t his usual style of song but I thought he did a good job proving that he really can sing.
Amy - Clearly Blake’s weakest performance of the night - but I mostly blame the song.
Andrew - Where the hell does Simon get off critizing Blake for that performance? (Give me another sentence to defend the boxed-in beatboxer, please!)
Blake - Good song. Ok vocal and performance.
HJ - Pitchy and he was doing the Pee Pee dance. I love Blake, but geesh this was screachy and torutury. (Editor’s note: tortury?)
Young Randall - Didn’t like it, and it sounded bad the whole way through, including a terrible last note.
Eddy Zucko - Blake says those song writers from Seattle should live together and get married like 2 sissies for making him sing this song.
The Bito~! - Not a fan of the song so much, but at least he tried his best. Kinda unfair, oh well.
Lionel Ritchie - He didn’t sing it as outrageously as he could’ve, but at least he put his all into it.
Judge for yourself.
Blake - This Is My Now
It’s Jordin’s turn and I think she kills this song and this will wrap it up for her. Let’s see if that’s the case. My dear mother is jinxing her. How’s that for unbiased guest judging? We’re about 30 seconds in and I think Blake is hiding. It’s kind of unfair because this is perfect for her. Maybe they should’ve given Blake Do I Make You Proud. If this were to play out like a singing competition, Jordin wins round three and the contest, but you know how that goes. It wasn’t as good as her second performance, but it was much better than Blake’s version of this song. Not even close. And she starts crying at the end. I might vote for her 200 times now. Wait, I’m supposed to be unbiased. Sorry about that. Randall says Jordin deserves it all. That made me happy until they panned to Constantine and I felt violated. Paula says Jordin freakin’ makes her proud. Yep, she said it. Simon says that last week he didn’t think she was good enough to make the finals and now he says that he’s wrong. He says it’s a singing competition and he just wiped the floor with Blake on that song. My mother got very upset with that one.
My dear mother - She did a great job. But the song was unfair to Blake because it was much better for Jordin.
Sis - It was good. Her second song was a lot better, but it was good.
Shoesless - It was solid and I think she just won the competition.
Jessica - Such a lovely girl, such a gorgeous voice, such a great dress, such a pathetic song.
Patty - This is how Carrie beat Bo and how Jordin will beat Blake.
George - Started strong, was soft when she needed to and didn’t need the big note.
Shantel - Her best of the night. The song was obviously MUCH better suited for her than Blake.
Amy - She’s got an unfair advantage since this song suits her exactly the way it didn’t suit Blake. Still, it was her weakest performance of the night.
Andrew - Well, duh. This Was Written For A Singer Like Her And So Of Course She Wins With A TKO.
Blake - Still a good song, but a way better performance and vocal. This is the next “A Moment Like This”.
HJ - I was expecting a different song. It fits her style of singing better, waiting for that big note, here it is…
Young Randall - Why are they singing the same song??? At any rate this one sounded like it was written for her. And she just blew it up. If Blake wins I do a one man riot.
Eddy Zucko - Jordin loves the song writers from Seattle, but she also says they should get married and live together like 2 sissies.
The Bito~! - She sang it much better. It wasn’t really fair at all, she would have lost if they sang a song that wasn’t her style.
Lionel Ritchie - Are we sure Jordin isn’t my daughter? I think her real name is Jordin Outrageous Ritchie.
Judge for yourself.
Jordin - This Is My Now
Blake started it off with a bang. Jordin finished it off with a bang. It’s her competition to lose. Eddy Zucko has been calling it since day one. It’s the only thing he’s ever gotten right in his life. I’m picking Jordin to win it even though I said just yesterday that Blake would win. She changed my vote. I did ask The Luchadors and Luchador 1 had to change his vote and he said that Jordin got more yes’s than Blake did from the judges. Luchador 2 said that I blog about him too much, but he said Jordin would win too. The woman who gave me the Luchadors said that Jordin is going to win, but the last song was unfair and Jesus said that Jordin was simply the better singer and she would win. Here are the rest.
My dear mother - I want Blake to win but I have a funny feeling Jordin is.
Sis - I want Blake to win.
Shoesless - Jordin, all the way.
Jessica - Jordin wins based on the entire season, but if it was based on tonight, Blake.
Patty - Jordin
George - Blake will be a monster recording artist, will sell many more albums and will not win American Idol because Jordin took him every round.
Shantel - Blake
Amy - Up until the final song I thought they were pretty evenly matched tonight. I think Blake was slightly better in the first round and Jordin was a little stronger in the second round. The third round clinched it for me - Jordin clearly won the night. And overall, I think Jordin will win the season. She’s more marketable than Blake and has wider potential appeal. Jordin is the American Idol.
Andrew - I picked Jordin to win this a LONG time ago, and I’m going to stick with that pick. But damn, if I don’t feel like Blake is being robbed blind by AI’s stupid devotion to theme weeks and formulaic, pablumatic, tepid “winner” songs.
Blake - Jordin wins. And a shout out to the runner-ups: Blake, Kat, Bo, Diana, Clay, Justin…and lest we forget…Brian Dunkleman.
HJ - I think Jordin will be the next American Idol.
Young Randall - Your winner by unanimous decision, Jordin Sparks.
Eddy Zucko - And the winner (like I’m going to change my pick now) Her Airness, Jordin Sparks.
The Bito~! (He boycotted his prediction because he was so upset with the last song.)
Lionel Ritchie - I think Jordin Ritchie, I mean Jordin Sparks wins in an outrageously close vote.
I’ll be back tomorrow night, but first, a shout out to Rickey.org for the audio. Seacrest out!
The Rest Of The Shows
American Idol Season 6 Preview
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 12
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 11
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 10
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 9
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 8
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 7
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 6
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 6 Part 2
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 4
American Idol Season 6: And Then There Were 3
American Idol Season 6 Wrap-Up And Finale Preview