Carly is gone. She shouldn’t have left. This is the first time this year where I can say that someone who had the talent to win was kicked off too early (I’m talking to you Michael Johns). At times, I really thought she had a chance to win. At other times, not so much. And that’s probably why she’s out. She was inconsistent when you expected her not to be.
The Hot List (based on last week’s performances)
1. David Cook – The two Davids are neck and neck.
1. David Archuleta – But I like the first David better so he’s on top.
3. Syesha Mercado – Slowly but surely, she snuck up on people.
4. Jason Castro’s Dread Locks – Unfortunately, his fan base is keeping him around.
5. Brooke White – Curly or straight tonight?
The Departed
1. Young David Hernandez
2. Young Amanda Overmyer
3. Young Chikezie
4. Young Ramiele Malubay
5. Old Michael Johns
6. Young Kristy Lee Cook
7. Young And Tattooed Carly Smithson
Tonight is Neil Diamond night. I guess American Idol is really going after that grandmotherly demographic. But I say that we make the most of it. The contestants are singing twice tonight, so this show is going to be quick without a lot of jibber jabber. Maybe that’s a good thing.
Joining me tonight as guest judge is Jessica. We haven’t really been on the same page as far as who we’ve liked week to week, so this should be interesting. Jessica also does a great impersonation of the American Idol come back from commercial music. Listen below.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download


