If I was live at American Idol last week, I would’ve made a sign that said, “If Casey Wins, We Riot”. And I would’ve been kicked out of the building, but that’s not the point. The point is, Casey making it to the final nearly became a reality and it would’ve been the biggest American Idol blunder since Chris Daughtry was kicked out with three weeks to go.
Thankfully, we didn’t have to riot.
People have faint memories of earlier in the season and maybe Crystal peaked too early, but I’m amazed at all the Lee DeWyze love. This is the same dude who slept-walked throughout the first half of the season. This is the same Lee DeWyze who still has issues answering questions without stuttering, looking down and perspiring heavily. I think he’s done really well in the last two weeks, but has he jumped ahead of Crystal in my book? No. I’ll take consistently good week after week, mature, polished, and someone with a bit of a rebellious streak in her over someone who has no idea how he got here.
The Hot List (based on last week’s performances)
1. Crystal Bowersox
2. Lee DeWyze
The Departed
1. Young Lacey Brown
2. Young Paige Miles
3. Young Didi Benami
4. Young Andrew Garcia
5. Young Katie Stevens
6. Young Tim Urban
7. Young Creepy Girl
8. Young Aaron Kelly
9. Young Michael Lynche
10. Young Casey James
Don’t forget that Lionel Richie will give me his thoughts tonight, like always on the final Tuesday night show.
Ryno says it’s Simon’s last week of shows. I’m already sad.
Lee looks scared out of his mind already. He may hyperventilate. Bowersox looks focused and excited.
There are three stages tonight.
1. Their favorite song they performed this season.
2. A track chosen by executive producer Simon Fuller.
3. Their first single if they win.
Stage 1
Crystal won the coin toss and she makes Lee go first. He’s singing The Boxer. This is the song he performed on the week that I missed the show. I can see why he picked it as it is a great way to start the show. But, his performance is pretty sleepy here. He needs to drink some coffee or something. Randall says it was a great way to start off the night, but he wants Lee to pick it up. Ellen says she couldn’t be prouder than if she birthed him herself. Kara says he has to punch harder. Simon says he expects more passion and excitement. Lionel says that it could’ve been outrageous, should’ve been outrageous, but was just outrageously decent.
Crystal is performing Me And Bobby McGee. The woman understands what night this is and gives an energetic, and slightly wild performance near the end. Good stuff. Randall thought it was dope. Ellen says it was stunning. Kara says she has fire in her belly tonight. Simon says she’s back on her best. Lionel says he knew Bobby McGee and she wasn’t as outrageous as Crystal was tonight.
Stage 2
Read More